POVERTY: Rethinking priorities

20 Jul 2010
Developments reported on TropIKA.net within the last few days have challenged some common assumptions made about the infectious diseases of poverty…
most of the really poor people in the world live in Africa; most fevers in Africa are caused by malaria; persistent brain damage is an inevitable consequence of cerebral malaria; we know (roughly) the prevalence of TB in countries like South Africa; childhood TB is not a priority area; pneumonia and diarrhoea are not neglected diseases; and innovations in medical research always happen in the North, not in disease-endemic countries themselves…
Whether these recent developments represent good news or bad, they call into question the ordering of many of the current priorities for research, policy and public health practice.
Researchers at Oxford University have applied a new “multidimensional poverty index”, to conclude that there are more poor people in eight of India’s states than in the 26 countries of sub-Saharan Africa combined [1]. Not everyone will agree with this analysis, but the infectious disease burden of India’s poor surely deserves to be accorded a higher priority.
It has for some years been believed that an African child with fever is most likely to have malaria. As confirmatory diagnostic tests are usually unavailable on the frontline of care, the practice of “presumptive” diagnosis and treatment is therefore recommended. However, a mathematical modelling study [2] has concluded that most fevers are not malaria. In some parts of Africa, 80% of children attending public clinics with fever are probably suffering from some other infection. The findings provide strong support for the new rapid diagnostic tests to be made available at all health facilities in Africa.
One of the most serious consequences of malaria is the lasting cognitive damage suffered by children who develop cerebral malaria. A very “early” study [3] with laboratory mice suggests that adding antioxidants to standard malaria treatment may help prevent this. (By coincidence, this research has been published within a few days of an analysis [4] appearing to show that a high prevalence of parasitic infections holds back rises in the average IQ in disease-endemic countries.)
http://blog.tropika.net/editorschoice/2010/07/20/rethinking-priorities/